School meals in Baden-Württemberg will not be required to contain meat or fish, as the VGH (State Health Agency) has decided against such an obligation.

Chowing Down on Carrots, Not Chicken Nuggets: Baden-Württemberg Court Denies Daily Meat/Fish in School Lunches

School meals in Baden-Württemberg will not be required to contain meat or fish, as the VGH (State Health Agency) has decided against such an obligation.

Social Media Links: Facebook ✏️ Twitter 🔥 Whatsapp 📧 Email 📜 Print 📋 Copy Link

A student in Baden-Württemberg isn't entitled to daily meat or fish options in their lunch trays, as ruled by the Baden-Württemberg Administrative Court of Appeal (VGH). The disappointed parents and their child from Constance couldn't make their case against a predominantly vegetarian school menu, as announced by the VGH on Thursday (9 S 1044/25).

With four school days, the pesky all-day school in Constance offers vegetarian or vegan dishes on three of them, and only meat or fish on the remaining day. Parents argued that this posed a risk of malnutrition and conflicts with their child's food intolerance. They attempted an urgent appeal at the Administrative Court in Freiburg but failed. Heartbroken, they visited the Administrative Court of Appeal (VGH) Baden-Württemberg, only for their appeal to be denied.

First, the parents' appeal was deemed inadmissible, as they had chosen to represent themselves, breaking the "lawyer's obligation" at the VGH. Daughter’s appeal was also rejected because she was not involved in the first procedure, making her ineligible for filing an appeal. That's the end of the story.

A Quick Peek into the VGH Appeal Process

The Administrative Court of Appeal (VGH) Baden-Württemberg plays an essential role in public administrative appeals in the German judiciary system. Here's what you should know:

• Jurisdiction and Competence: The Administrative Court of Appeal (VGH) Baden-Württemberg hears appeals on decisions made by local administrative courts (Verwaltungsgericht, VG) in the region.
• Appeal Requirements: Appeals to the VGH typically stem from judgments issued by the first-instance Administrative Court (VG). These appeals must be made within a specified deadline after the VG decision comes out. There's usually a one-month window for appeals. These appeals must be well-argued using legal reasons, pointing out how the lower court made a mistake.
• School Lunch Menu Cases: Issues like school lunch menus generally represent public administrative decisions involving local school authorities or municipalities, concerning complaints about the content, quality, or provision of meals.
• Formal Procedures: Appeals must be filed in writing with the administrative court. Legal representation may be required at the VGH level. The appeal process involves written submissions and possibly oral hearings.

So, Why Was That Student Out of Lunch?

The student's calamity in the lunch line can be attributed to the parents' informal approach to the appeal process, as they did not have a lawyer to represent them at the VGH level. Further, the daughter lacked standing as she was not involved in the first instance procedure. Moral of the story? Stick to those legal requirements and grab a tasty, nutritious vegetarian meal in Baden-Württemberg!

References: ntv.de and AFP

Fun Fact: If you didn't know, the administrative court system in Germany can be fascinating to explore. Next time you're bored, why not research historic cases, procedures, or its impact on society? You might uncover some fascinating insights!

1. In light of the denial of a daily meat or fish option in school lunches, parents might consider vocational training in law to better navigate future appeals, enhancing their community policy knowledge.
2. With the emphasis on healthy diets and nutrition, a nutrition and health-and-wellness focused vocational training program could provide valuable insights for parents seeking to ensure their children's balanced meals at schools.
3. In the broader context of the educational system, understanding politics and general news can help parents appreciate the processes and decisions behind school lunches, potentially advocating for policies that promote balanced and inclusive menus.

Read also: